Skip to FiltersReport abuse
2,045 listings
- $18,740great price$3,130 below market
- 43,405 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Mike Smith Buick GMC (19 mi away)
Close
Located in Lockport, NY / 19 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAJC8JH508015
Stock: T5171A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-11-2025 - New Listing$18,240good price$2,371 below market
- 43,825 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Basil Toyota (19 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Lockport, NY / 19 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC9JH490232
Stock: 250554A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-22-2025 - $14,493fair price$1,127 below market
- 99,764 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl manual
- Ken Ganley Subaru Wickliffe (160 mi away)
Close
Located in Wickliffe, OH / 160 miles away from Buffalo, NY
Ganley Subaru East offers some of the best values in the market. We have a huge selection of new and used Subaru vehicles as well as an extensive Used...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
24 Combined MPG (22 City/28 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC2JG404023
Stock: 32209T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-27-2025 - $16,972fair price$439 below market
- 89,949 miles
- 2 accidents, 3 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- W & L Subaru (174 mi away)
Close
Located in Northumberland, PA / 174 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC1JH474056
Stock: 27992B
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-19-2025 
Photos not available$18,465good price$935 below market- 65,052 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Lia Honda Williamsville (11 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Williamsville, NY / 11 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC8JH555197
Stock: JH555197T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-22-2025- New Listing$17,581fair price$435 below market
- 88,836 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Driveway (177 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Coraopolis, PA / 177 miles away from Buffalo, NY
CarFax No Accidents Reported,Back-Up Camera,Blind Spot Monitor,Bluetooth,Brake Assist,Heated Seats,Lane Departure Warning,Lane Keeping Assist,Satellit...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC1JH524239
Stock: SP6598
Certified Pre-Owned: No - New Listing$17,169fair price$56 below market
- 90,138 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Driveway (172 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Pittsburgh, PA / 172 miles away from Buffalo, NY
CarFax No Accidents Reported,Back-Up Camera,Bluetooth,Brake Assist,Heated Seats,Satellite Radio,Sunroof / Moonroof,4 Cylinder Engine,4-Wheel Disc Brak...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC5JH490339
Stock: S490339A
Certified Pre-Owned: No - $16,040fair price$488 above market
- 114,361 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Park Maple City Dodge Chrysler Jeep Ram (71 mi away)
Close
Located in Hornell, NY / 71 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAJC8JH460869
Stock: A60869
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-11-2025 - $16,980fair price$37 above market
- 111,727 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Park Maple City Dodge Chrysler Jeep Ram (71 mi away)
Close
Located in Hornell, NY / 71 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAJC4JH494906
Stock: A94906
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-15-2025 - 38,068 miles
- Insurance loss reported, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford (171 mi away)
Close
Located in Bedford, OH / 171 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Issue reported
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJABC9JH425157
Stock: 425157S01
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-09-2025- $16,440fair price$14 above market
- 104,390 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Huebner Subaru (196 mi away)
Close
Located in Carrollton, OH / 196 miles away from Buffalo, NY
1-OWNER -- AWD -- 32 MPG HWY -- PANORAMIC SUNROOF -- HEATED SEATS & MIRRORS -- BACKUP CAMERA -- STARLINK 7” TOUCHSCREEN -- ALL-WEATHER PACKAGE -- POWE...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: Yes
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC1JH520842
Stock: 71541A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-28-2025 - $17,000fair price$560 above market
- 119,265 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Huebner Subaru (196 mi away)
Close
Located in Carrollton, OH / 196 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AWD -- 2.0L TURBO BOXER ENGINE -- HEATED LEATHER SEATS -- PANORAMIC SUNROOF -- EYESIGHT SAFETY SUITE -- HARMAN KARDON AUDIO -- NAVIGATION SYSTEM -- PO...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
25 Combined MPG (23 City/27 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJGWCXJH535471
Stock: 71186B
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-01-2025 - New Listing$18,759fair price$436 above market
- 82,293 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Bill Rapp GMC (141 mi away)
Close
Located in Syracuse, NY / 141 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC4JH593610
Stock: S33257DA
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-29-2025 - New Listing
- 74,859 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Carvana - Cleveland (175 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Cleveland, OH / 175 miles away from Buffalo, NY
At Carvana, we go miles beyond the extra mile. That's why we provide you with a convenient, fast, and hassle-free car buying experience that puts you ...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC5JH465182
Stock: 2003672943
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-23-2025 - 64,539 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- W & L Subaru (174 mi away)
Close
Located in Northumberland, PA / 174 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAWC6JH477551
Stock: 27795A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 12-22-2024- 101,000 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Jeff Kies Auto Sales (151 mi away)
Close
Located in Apalachin, NY / 151 miles away from Buffalo, NY
Buckle up, because this Dark Gray Metallic 2018 Subaru Forester is ready to take you on an adventure like no other! With its sleek design and powerful...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGCXJH470777
Stock: 22983
Certified Pre-Owned: No- 114,385 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- W & L Subaru (174 mi away)
Close
Located in Northumberland, PA / 174 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC6JH426954
Stock: 28290B
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-09-2025- 33,977 miles
- 2 accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Ken Ganley Ford Parma (179 mi away)
Close
Located in Parma, OH / 179 miles away from Buffalo, NY
2018 Crystal Black Silica Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium LOCAL TRADE, ONE OWNER!!, Forester 2.5i Premium, 4D Sport Utility, AWD, 4-Wheel Disc Brakes, 6 ...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC5JH603171
Stock: 22861P
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-08-2025- New Listing
- 45,448 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Bill Rapp GMC (141 mi away)
Close
Located in Syracuse, NY / 141 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC2JH617578
Stock: US199A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-08-2025 - 72,619 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- W & L Subaru (174 mi away)
Close
Located in Northumberland, PA / 174 miles away from Buffalo, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC3JH494256
Stock: 27994A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-06-2025- Price Drop
- 132,699 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Driveway (172 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Pittsburgh, PA / 172 miles away from Buffalo, NY
CarFax 1-Owner,Rare Find,Back-Up Camera,Blind Spot Monitor,Bluetooth,Brake Assist,Heated Seats,Leather Seats,Satellite Radio,Sunroof / Moonroof,4 Cyli...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAJC9JH600461
Stock: S600461A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Showing 1 - 21 out of 2,045 listings
Consumer Reviews for the Subaru Forester
Read recent reviews for the Subaru Forester
Better than Expected
Mark in the North Georgia Mountains, 05/01/2018
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i 4dr SUV AWD (2.5L 4cyl 6M)
We purchased a base model 2018 Forester as an economical everyday/trip vehicle to replace our 16 year old Mazda hatchback. We needed something with a little more room, but was still economical to own and operate. Another requisite was a manual transmission which is getting harder to find outside of sport models, but was still available in the Forester. This is our first Subaru, and we … hope their reputation for durability and reliability are warranted. The vehicle has so far (1600 miles and about a month of use), proven to be better than expected. The interior comfort, quietness of the cabin at speed, ride quality, ease of entry and exit, storage space, and fuel economy have all been excellent. The fuel economy has been a surprise (over 29 mpg combined), in that we exceed the EPA estimates for the model without really trying. The manual 6 speed shifts well and the engine has plenty of power and torque for everyday driving. It has a roomy and comfortable back seat capable of long trips with little trouble. The only criticism so far is that some of the interior materials seem to have hard plastic finishes. The base infotainment stereo unit has an excellent sound and easy Bluetooth connectability, as well as great radio reception, and shockingly, a CD player for us old folks that like such things. The standard backup camera comes in handy for parking in tight places. It handles well on our mountain roads with some expected body lean (for the class of vehicle), and tracks well through the curves. The turning radius is excellent for a vehicle of it's size, for great maneuverability in tight spaces. The all wheel drive and ground clearance will come in handy for exploring the Forest Service roads around here, and when the snow is an issue. Overall, we are very pleased so far with the purchase. Update 11/1/2018 - We have now owned the Forester for 7 months and 9800 miles and are still very pleased with it. One thing I neglected to mention in the earlier review was how fantastic the brakes are in this thing. They have great pedal feel and stop the vehicle very quickly, which has come in handy on a number of occasions. The visibility from the cabin is much better than on any of our other vehicles which helps with confidence on the road. Plus we are still getting over 29 mpg combined mileage. I was disappointed to hear that Subaru has dropped the manual transmission option from the 2019 Forester, and hope they reconsider it in later years for those of us who prefer them. Update 11/1/2019 - We have had the Forester for a year and a half with over 21,000 miles on the odometer, and are still pleased with the purchase. We have had no issues at all and are still getting 29 mpg combined. If I had to nitpick, I would wish for the original equipment tires on the base model to have a little more aggressive AT style tread and a higher treadwear warranty, as the current tires are showing significant wear at this point. Given that we live in the mountains and have pretty much continuous curves and hills to traverse, I'm not surprised with the tire wear, but one can wish. Update 5/1/2020 - We have had the Forester for a little over 2 years now and the vehicle is still running great with no issues at all. Still comfortable, quiet, over 29 mpg combined, and holds contents like Hermione's purse. Still very happy with the purchase with no regrets. Update:5/4/2021 - Forester still running well, but I have 2 improvements to suggest to Subaru. First, at 32k miles, the OEM Yokohama tires are mostly shot, and have been getting more and more squirrelly in the rain for quite a while. Better, deeper grooved more AT type tires would be an improvement. Second, the rear brake pads are about in need of replacement with normal driving, which is way sooner than any other vehicle I have owned. Larger pads and/or calipers from the factory would be a great improvement, so that all four wheel's brakes could be replaced at the same time. Still comfortable and dependable, however. Update - 5/2022 - A little over 4 years and 40k miles and still happy with it. We replaced the OE tires at 38k miles, as they were shot and really bad in the rain. The Cooper CS5 Grand Tourings we put on are a huge improvement in wet and dry handling, although they are a tad less fuel efficient. Still averaging 29 MPG overall, comfortable, and reliable. Update 11/2023 - Over 50K miles now, with no issues and just basic maintenance costs. Still reliable, comfortable, and 29 mpg over the life of the car. Happy wth the car, and hoping it lasts a long, long time with the current vehicle pricing up to what it is now thanks to inflation and regulatory pressures. 5/2024 - Still going strong with no issues.
Used 2018 Subaru Forester in Buffalo, NY Values
Estimated values
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited 4dr SUV AWD (2.5L 4cyl CVT) with no options
| Condition | Trade-In | Private Party | Dealer Retail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outstanding | $14,487 | $17,096 | $19,257 |
| Clean | $13,907 | $16,391 | $18,440 |
| Average | $12,940 | $15,216 | $17,078 |
| Rough | $11,683 | $13,689 | $15,308 |
The average list price of a used 2018 Subaru Forester in Buffalo, New York is $18,047. The average mileage on a used Subaru Forester 2018 for sale in Buffalo, New York is 82,409. Based on the average mileage of 82,409 for used 2018 Subaru Forester for sale in Buffalo, NY and using an average vehicle condition rating, which means the vehicle may have a few mechanical and/or cosmetic problems and may require a considerable amount of reconditioning, we appraise the average trade-in value of a used Subaru Forester 2018 in Buffalo, New York to be $12,940.
Filters
Skip to ResultsApplied Filters4Active
Make & Model
Year
New / Used
Price & Payments
Price Rating
Body Type
Trim
Mileage
Accidents & History
Engine & Drivetrain
Exterior Color
Interior Color
Total Seating
Edmunds Review
Features
Options & Packages
MPG
* Delivery of any kind does not apply to Alaska and Hawaii. Contact the dealer for delivery details, restrictions and costs.