Skip to FiltersReport abuse
786 listings
- $14,995great price$3,147 below market
- 44,900 miles
- 2 accidents, 2 owners, corporate fleet vehicle
- 4cyl automatic
- A Better Way Wholesale Autos (72 mi away)
Close
Located in Naugatuck, CT / 72 miles away from New York, NY
- **Low Mileage & Reliable Performance:** With just 44,900 miles, this 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium offers a robust 2.5L H4 engine delivering 175hp...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAF61K3041430
Stock: 41430N
Certified Pre-Owned: No - New Listing$14,600great price$2,639 below market
- 53,818 miles
- 1 accident, 3 owners, rental vehicle
- 4cyl automatic
- Maserati of Monmouth (36 mi away)
Close
Located in Ocean Township, NJ / 36 miles away from New York, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAB69K3012778
Stock: K3012778
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-01-2025 - Price Drop$14,990great price$1,488 below market
- 95,080 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Matt Blatt Mitsubishi (93 mi away)
Close
Located in Glassboro, NJ / 93 miles away from New York, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAR66K3031665
Stock: M25024A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-07-2025 - 36,500 miles
- Frame damage reported, 2 owners, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- A Better Way Wholesale Autos (72 mi away)
Close
Located in Naugatuck, CT / 72 miles away from New York, NY
- Low mileage of 36,500 miles on a trusted 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited. - Stunning blue exterior with luxurious tan leather-trimmed interior. - ...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Issue reported
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: Yes
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAN62K3023598
Stock: 23598NL
Certified Pre-Owned: No- $19,195good price$1,517 below market
- 48,301 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Driveway (34 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in North Brunswick, NJ / 34 miles away from New York, NY
CarFax No Accidents Reported,CarFax 1-Owner,Rare Find,Apple CarPlay,Back-Up Camera,Blind Spot Monitor,Bluetooth,Brake Assist,Heated Seats,Keyless Star...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAS6XK3008156
Stock: SW526002A
Certified Pre-Owned: No - Price Drop$16,990fair price$264 below market
- 100,598 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Carvana - Philadelphia (77 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Philadelphia, PA / 77 miles away from New York, NY
At Carvana, we go miles beyond the extra mile. That's why we provide you with a convenient, fast, and hassle-free car buying experience that puts you ...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAS67K3021205
Stock: 2003635755
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-10-2025 - $8,999great price$4,225 below market
- 116,836 miles
- No accidents, 3 owners, corporate fleet vehicle
- 4cyl automatic
- Auto Spot (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Wood-Ridge, NJ / 10 miles away from New York, NY
Price includes all costs to be paid by consumer, except for licensing costs, registration fees, retail package, title and taxes. Any monetary discount...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAF61J3044343
Stock: 044343-43
Certified Pre-Owned: No - Price Drop$8,999great price$2,855 below market
- 138,585 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Auto Spot (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Wood-Ridge, NJ / 10 miles away from New York, NY
Price includes all costs to be paid by consumer, except for licensing costs, registration fees, retail package, title and taxes. Any monetary discount...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAC60J3027618
Stock: 027618-18
Certified Pre-Owned: No - New Listing
- 26,896 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- CarMax Easton (69 mi away)
Close
Located in Easton, PA / 69 miles away from New York, NY
CarMax values transparency and wants you to love your next car, not settle on it. Certain vehicles may have unrepaired safety recalls. Check nhtsa.gov...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAF65K3022329
Stock: 26118761
Certified Pre-Owned: No - New Listing$16,496great price$3,760 below market
- 59,188 miles
- 4cyl automatic
- Habberstad BMW (32 mi away)
Close
Located in Huntington Station, NY / 32 miles away from New York, NY
Clean CARFAX. 2020 Subaru Legacy Premium Magnetite Gray Metallic AWD Lineartronic CVT Local Trade, Nonsmoker, Extended Warranty Available, New Tires.&...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary Unavailable.
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAE64L3029417
Stock: BU6230T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 02-04-2025 - New ListingNot Priced
- 54,990 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Colonial Subaru (54 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Danbury, CT / 54 miles away from New York, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAH66K3018013
Stock: N8500A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-17-2025 - New Listing$13,995good price$1,698 below market
- 71,123 miles
- No accidents, 3 owners, corporate fleet vehicle
- 4cyl automatic
- A Better Way Wholesale Autos (72 mi away)
Close
Located in Naugatuck, CT / 72 miles away from New York, NY
- Sleek and efficient with only 71,123 miles on the clock. - Equipped with a powerful 2.5L H4 engine and 6-Speed Shiftable CVT. - Premium tech featu...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAF65J3008736
Stock: 8736N
Certified Pre-Owned: No - $15,955good price$1,011 below market
- 94,557 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, corporate fleet vehicle
- 4cyl automatic
- Star Auto Mall 512 (74 mi away)
Close
Located in Bethlehem, PA / 74 miles away from New York, NY
This 2020 Subaru Legacy Premium is a stylish 4D sedan in Ice Silver, featuring a well-maintained 2.5L 4-Cylinder DOHC 16V engine paired with a Lineart...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC64L3006190
Stock: U10021
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 02-14-2025 - $19,490fair price$284 below market
- 44,415 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Honda of Hackettstown (44 mi away)
Close
Located in Hackettstown, NJ / 44 miles away from New York, NY
Heated Seats, Smart Device Integration, Lane Keeping Assist, Brake Actuated Limited Slip Differential, Apple CarPlay®, Dual Zone A/C, Remote Engine St...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC68L3011019
Stock: T16718
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-14-2025 - $15,283fair price$145 below market
- 119,547 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Lia Honda Brewster NY (49 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Brewster, NY / 49 miles away from New York, NY
Recent Arrival! Blind Spot Detection (BSD)/RCTA System, Brake assist, BSD w/RCTA & Keyless Access & LED Fog Lights, Electronic Stability Control, Exte...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC61L3014702
Stock: L3014702T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-31-2025 - Price Drop$20,675fair price$336 below market
- 36,547 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Victory Subaru (33 mi away)
Close
Located in Somerset, NJ / 33 miles away from New York, NY
Recent Arrival! 2020 Subaru Legacy Whc *** CLEAN CARFAX - RUNS LIKE NEW!!! *** AM/FM radio: SiriusXM, Auto-Dimming Mirror w/Compass, Automatic tempera...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC60L3029188
Stock: L3029188
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-05-2025 - New Listing$16,991fair price$416 below market
- 78,747 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Sullivan Honda (88 mi away)
Close
Located in Torrington, CT / 88 miles away from New York, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAN69J3031681
Stock: 25246A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-19-2025 - 35,913 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 4cyl automatic
- Toyota Universe (15 mi away)
Close
Located in Little Falls, NJ / 15 miles away from New York, NY
Toyota Universe is pumped up to offer this attractive-looking 2020 Subaru Legacy in Ice Silver Metallic. This vehicle has been through our award-winni...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC69L3023275
Stock: L3023275
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-16-2025- Price Drop$20,499fair price$580 above market
- 72,615 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Auto Spot (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Wood-Ridge, NJ / 10 miles away from New York, NY
Price includes all costs to be paid by consumer, except for licensing costs, registration fees, retail package, title and taxes. Any monetary discount...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAG69L3033380
Stock: 033380-80
Certified Pre-Owned: No - $17,311fair price$169 above market
- 79,398 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- Haldeman Subaru (49 mi away)
Close
Located in Robbinsville, NJ / 49 miles away from New York, NY
Legacy Premium, AWD, Crystal Black Silica, Slate Black w/Cloth Upholstery. 27/35 City/Highway MPG2020 Subaru Legacy Premium
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
30 Combined MPG (27 City/35 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BWAC68L3021498
Stock: S25425A
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 02-28-2025 - Price Drop$16,800fair price$39 below market
- 76,522 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 4cyl automatic
- AutoPROVED (77 mi away)
Close
Located in Allentown, PA / 77 miles away from New York, NY
Thank you for choosing AutoPROVED, where Cars Cost Less and home of No Haggle Pricing. All of our vehicles go through a RIGOROUS 118pt inspection and ...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (25 City/34 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: 4S3BNAN67J3046891
Stock: A2504103
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-10-2025
Showing 1 - 21 out of 786 listings
Consumer Reviews for the Subaru Legacy
Read recent reviews for the Subaru Legacy
First 1500 Miles
pluffs, 04/02/2019
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium 4dr Sedan AWD (2.5L 4cyl CVT)
I purchased a 2019 Subaru Legacy Premium with the Blind Spot Detection, Rear Cross Traffic Alert and Fog Lights package in February 2019. This was after at least a year of toying with the idea of getting a new car. I compared this against the new Accord, Forester, Ascent, Santa Fe, Sonata, Tucson, among others. I didn’t have an exact type of car in mind, I wanted something comfortable, … safe, reasonably priced and that wasn’t overstated in its outward appearance. After many test drives of all the cars and trips to the dealership to look at the cars in person, I decided to get the Legacy. It had the best blend of all my checkmarks and considering the favorable financing terms and the new model for 2020, I hoped I could also make it the most financially attractive car as well.
I am lucky where I live to have a handful of Subaru dealerships within an hour or two from my house. I played the game and shopped around to each, each time chipping away at the bottom line price. I finally found a price where I thought I was just wasting time if I continued so I decided to buy.
I’ve now got about 1,500 miles on the car and have some things I love about it and some I do not like at all.
Pros
- Comfort. This car is seriously comfortable and plush for the price range. Short or long trips are a breeze.
- MPG. With mixed driving, I am getting a little north of 31 MPG, which was a very pleasant surprise.
- Tech. I find the infotainment system and menu are easy to understand and navigate.
- Stock radio in the premium trim. I was on the fence about upgrading to Limited to get the upgraded speaker system. I am glad I didn’t. I am not a complete audiophile, but I want my radio to sound good. I find the stock 6 speaker system in the Legacy Premium to have clean, punchy bass and clear highs.
- Cell phone holder. I have a mid-sized Google Pixel and there is a place where my cell phone can rest easily near the shifter. This is a small pro, but I find it very helpful and practical. I think Subaru may not label this specifically as a cell phone holder, but for my sized phone, it fits great.
- Eyesight. So far it works great. It gently nudges me when I get to close to either side of the road. The adaptive cruise control is fantastic for highway driving. So far it works as advertised and is great to have as my last car didn’t have any updated tech or safety in it.
Cons
- Interior Rattles. This is by far and away the biggest complaint I have. The driver's side door, steering column and dash all rattle randomly when going over rough roads. Sometimes they don’t, other times it’s very intense, which makes bringing it in for warranty service difficult as it’s not 100% reproducible all the time. I did this once already and I received a hard time from the dealer when asking them to look into this and resolve it. They were able to take care of one in the door, but the dash/steering column are still problematic. I’m going to try a different dealer closer to home and see if they can help.
- Reflections from the bright sun. Since the interior is a lot of piano black and glass around the dash and controls, reflections are a serious concern. If the sun is just right, it can cause a glare which can make you want to squint or turn your head out of instinct.
- Touchscreen. While I find it works great, it is a fingerprint magnet. It also seems to not be able to absorb and hide gentle surface scratches. You have to be very careful to not touch the screen with anything that could cause a superficial surface scratch.
Ride quality is just what I wanted. A middle ground between absorbing all road imperfections and a sporty feel. The car has a nice, heavy stance and handles well when taking corners. As others have pointed out, there is a lack of real power but for the majority of drivers, I don’t foresee it being a big problem. If you need a performance vehicle I’d look elsewhere. Seating room is great, I can fit 4 full sized adults in the car with plenty of space to spare.
So far I am happy with my purchase. The pros outweigh the cons and if I can get the rattling taken care of I’d be over the moon. Hopefully, I can get some help from a more friendly and capable dealership.
Used 2019 Subaru Legacy in New York, NY Values
Estimated values
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium 4dr Sedan AWD (2.5L 4cyl CVT) with no options
| Condition | Trade-In | Private Party | Dealer Retail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outstanding | $13,154 | $15,779 | $18,125 |
| Clean | $12,774 | $15,308 | $17,566 |
| Average | $12,141 | $14,523 | $16,633 |
| Rough | $11,319 | $13,501 | $15,421 |
The average list price of a used 2019 Subaru Legacy in New York, New York is $16,392. The average mileage on a used Subaru Legacy 2019 for sale in New York, New York is 70,718. Based on the average mileage of 70,718 for used 2019 Subaru Legacy for sale in New York, NY and using an average vehicle condition rating, which means the vehicle may have a few mechanical and/or cosmetic problems and may require a considerable amount of reconditioning, we appraise the average trade-in value of a used Subaru Legacy 2019 in New York, New York to be $12,141.
Filters
Skip to ResultsApplied Filters4Active
Make & Model
Year
New / Used
Price & Payments
Price Rating
Body Type
Trim
Mileage
Accidents & History
Engine & Drivetrain
Exterior Color
Interior Color
Total Seating
Edmunds Review
Features
Options & Packages
MPG
* Delivery of any kind does not apply to Alaska and Hawaii. Contact the dealer for delivery details, restrictions and costs.