Looking at it on paper, you'd expect the Golf R to drive like a GTI with a little extra hot sauce to help VW justify the price difference. But right out of the gate it becomes abundantly clear that the new R is not a GTI "plus." It's a completely unique experience that might just make it the pick of the litter this time around.
The R's 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder shares its general architecture with the lesser GTI, but it's been juiced up to 315 horsepower and 280 lb-ft of torque with the manual transmission (and 295 lb-ft if you spring for the automatic). The extra power and torque are immediately noticeable, and the R rushes to its 7,000-rpm redline from anything above 4,000 rpm quicker and with far more gusto than the GTI.
The new R's trick all-wheel-drive system puts down power with zero fuss. You can feel the differentials cleverly shuffling the engine's available torque from wheel to wheel from the seat of your pants. The AWD and sticky rubber mean grip is made available at all times in most conditions, even the wet. Switch the stability control to its Sport setting and the R will do neat little powerslides out of pretty much any second- or third-gear corner. It's fun, but it won't let you get into any real trouble.
Since the U.S. and Canada are the only two markets that get the six-speed, we jumped at the chance to sample the three-pedal option. Unfortunately, the manual might be where R is least engaging. The gearing itself is excellent, allowing you to effectively use second and third during sportier driving on twisty roads. On highway driving, sixth gear is tall enough to keep the engine at a low enough rpm to give both efficiency and quietude.
The shifter itself is a bit lazy, and the notchy lever feels like more of an afterthought. The Golf R's closest rival, the Honda Civic Type R, has a manual you have to shift with intent, even on the day-to-day. The Golf's can be approached with seriousness or nonchalance, and the car neither rewards nor punishes. That might be fine for some, but the Golf R is for enthusiasts and we think the manual might leave them wanting more.
But the magic of the new Golf R isn't in its shifter — it's in the gutsy engine and that very clever AWD system. It might leave a few of the more visceral elements of a true driver's car on the table, but there's little doubt this is one of the fastest and most capable small cars hot-hatch enthusiasts have ever been able to buy. If you want something fast, practical, good-looking and shockingly capable, the Golf R is one of the best options on sale right now.