2024 Volvo XC60 T8 Polestar Engineered

The X3 is more performance-oriented than the XC60, with livelier handling and steering that makes it more fun to drive on a twisty road. Power and fuel economy are pretty even, but we give the edge to the Volvo's plusher and roomier interior. The BMW, though, offers a little more headroom for taller passengers and significantly more cargo space.

The Genesis GV70 is a relative newcomer, debuting just two years ago, but it made a memorable first impression with its bold styling and value. The GV70 base trim offers more standard features than the XC60 (larger infotainment display, Android Auto, wireless charging), makes more power from its larger four-cylinder engine, and has more cargo capacity. It may lack some of the Volvo's brand cachet, but it costs less and comes with a more generous warranty. We've picked it as the top small luxury SUV in our rankings.

Last year's full redesign of the Mercedes-Benz GLC returned it to its rightful place near the top of the small luxury SUV class, edged out only by the Genesis GV70 in Edmunds' rankings. Smooth and efficient power, a high-class interior and sophisticated in-car technology make the GLC a tough rival. The Benz offers cushier ride quality but costs more as well.